FORMAL ADMINISTRATIVE FILING — REVISED WRITTEN ANSWER AND DEFENSE (VERSION 7)
SAMUEL WAYNE PETTIGREW
dba PETTIGREW WELL DRILLING & PUMP REPAIR
Respondent — In Propria Persona (Pro Per)
📍 10641 Allen Way, Lucerne Valley, CA 92356
📞 (442) 242-2912 | 📞 (909) 615-9662
FILED VIA ELECTRONIC SUBMISSION TO CSLB INTAKE AND MEDIATION CENTER
TO:
-
Contractors State License Board
Intake and Mediation Center
State of California
[Recipient Address — Edit as Needed]
RE: Answer and Defense — CSLB Complaint No. NA 2026008115
I. FORMAL STATEMENT OF RESPONSE AND OVERVIEW
COMES NOW Respondent, Samuel Wayne Pettigrew, dba Pettigrew Well Drilling & Pump Repair, appearing in propria persona, and submits this Revised Formal Written Answer and Affirmative Defense (Version 7) to CSLB Complaint No. NA 2026008115 filed by Complainant Elizabeth G. Aguilar.
Respondent respectfully requests that the Contractors State License Board (CSLB) Intake and Mediation Center review the complete contractual terms, subterranean factual realities, operational record, and documentary evidence governing this residential water well project located at 25237 Kensington St., Apple Valley, CA 92307 (APN 0463-261-48-0000).
INCORPORATION OF COMPLAINANT'S EXHIBITS BY REFERENCE
Respondent notes that Complainant has already attached and submitted multiple physical copies of the primary Ground Water Institute of California (GWIC) Standard Form Drilling Contract (dated October 28, 2025) and the subsequent handwritten note (dated July 18, 2026) as part of her formal CSLB Complaint packet. The existence and execution of the original October 28, 2025 contract are undisputed. To avoid duplicating CSLB record files, Respondent hereby incorporates Complainant's attached complaint exhibits by reference into this Answer for all evidentiary and legal defense purposes.
As set forth in detail below, Respondent has at all times acted in good faith, performed substantial drilling work under operational and subterranean challenges, and adhered strictly to the express terms of the written agreement:
- Agreed 400-Foot Depth Scope: Under Section 2 of the executed agreement (Complainant's Exhibit), the contract explicitly defined the scope of work to attempt drilling down to a benchmark depth of 400 feet (at $100 per foot, total contract price $40,000). Respondent actively prosecuted this work, drilling through high-desert rock strata to 300 feet in pursuit of a viable water aquifer before Complainant expressly stopped the work and breached the contract.
- Allocation of Initial $4,000 Payment: The initial $4,000 received at signing was not an unearned deposit. It was allocated directly to essential pre-drilling costs, including a $2,000 fixed equipment move-on fee (non-footage transport charge), over $800+ in county permit fees and third-party permit representative handling costs, as well as specialized drill bits and mud-drilling equipment/supplies required to handle the local subterranean geology.
- Broad Preliminary Estimate on Permit Depth: The entry of "120 feet" on San Bernardino County Permit WP0040536 was a broad preliminary estimate submitted by the third-party permit processing representative. In well drilling, permit applications state initial estimated figures, as subterranean water table depths cannot be fixed prior to drilling and frequently require going deeper to strike water. The executed contract explicitly authorized drilling up to 400 feet, and 120 feet is hydrogeologically incapable of reaching groundwater in this sub-basin.
- Excusable Operational Challenges: Project timelines were impacted by events beyond contractor control:
- Initial Startup Delay: The start of drilling was delayed because a prior project took longer than anticipated.
- Equipment Breakdown on Rig 1: After initial mobilization, Rig 1 suffered a hydraulic pump failure requiring approximately $7,000 in repairs to avoid shutdown, prompting the mobilization of Rig 2.
- Fuel Price Inflation: A surge in regional diesel fuel prices from $4.50 to $8.00 per gallon significantly increased operational overhead.
- Unreasonable Client Interference, Early Breach & Equipment Retention: Respondent made continuous good-faith efforts to accommodate Complainant despite encountering severe, unreasonable client harassment, constant high-frequency demands outside contract terms, and hostility. Complainant ultimately reneged on the contractual agreement by issuing an explicit order barring Respondent from entering the property on November 6, 2026. Furthermore, Complainant continues to refuse Respondent access to retrieve his heavy drilling equipment from the parcel, causing severe operational hardship and delaying Respondent's work on other jobs.
- Reinstated Active C-57 License: Respondent held an active C-57 License throughout all physical drilling operations (October 28, 2025 – October 31, 2026). The brief administrative expiration after October 31, 2026, resulted from renewal processing delays caused by client non-payment on separate accounts. As of Wednesday, November 18, 2026, Respondent's C-57 License (No. 1045746) is officially reinstated to full active status.
Respondent respectfully requests a full dismissal of the complaint, as no statutory violations of the California Business and Professions Code have occurred.
II. FACTUAL AND CONTRACTUAL BACKGROUND
2.1 Incorporation of Undisputed Written Agreement (Complainant's Exhibit)
On October 28, 2025, Respondent and Complainant executed a written agreement using the Ground Water Institute of California (GWIC) Standard Form Drilling Contract for a residential water well project. Complainant has attached true and correct copies of this executed agreement as exhibits to her CSLB Complaint, and Respondent hereby incorporates those exhibits by reference.
Under Section 2 of the executed agreement, the contract explicitly defined the scope of work:
"THIS AGREEMENT WILL BE CONSIDERED COMPLETE WHEN:
1. SUFFICIENT WATER IS OBTAINED, OR;
2. PURCHASER REQUESTS THAT DRILLING BE STOPPED, OR;
3. THE 400 FEET, OR; $100.00 per foot
4. AT THE DISCRETION OF THE DRILLING CONTRACTOR, IF HE FEELS THAT CONTINUATION OF THE DRILLING OPERATIONS WOULD BE IMPRACTICAL."
The total contract price was $40,000, calculated at $100.00 per foot up to the 400-foot contractual ceiling. Payment was structured under explicit milestone terms:
- Initial Allocation ($4,000 Cash, Oct 28, 2025): Earmarked for pre-drilling mobilization, permits, and consumable equipment, comprising a $2,000 equipment move-on fee (flat fee for rig mobilization), $800+ for county permit filing fees and third-party permit representative processing, and specialized drill bits and mud-drilling tools/supplies.
- Milestone 2 ($16,000 Cashier's Check, March 18, 2026): Paid upon delivery and setup of heavy rotary drilling machinery on-site.
- Milestone 3 ($10,000): Due when bore hole is complete and ready for casing (Unbilled; unreached due to site ban).
- Milestone 4 ($10,000): Due when ready for pump installation (Unbilled; unreached due to site ban).
Section 4 explicitly excluded pump equipment and installation from the primary drilling contract price.
2.2 Express Risk Allocation and Exculpatory Terms
The executed written contract contains risk-allocation provisions establishing that water well drilling is an uncertain, hazardous subterranean operation:
- No Water Guarantee (Section 8.1.1): Respondent does not warrant or guarantee the discovery, quality, or quantity of water. Failure to strike water does not relieve Purchaser of payment obligations.
- Contractor Discretion & Impracticality (Section 8.1.2): Respondent retains sole discretion to alter hole size or discontinue drilling if subsurface conditions render operations impractical, while remaining entitled to full payment for work performed.
- Exemption from Delay Liability (Section 8.1.3): Respondent "shall not be liable for any damage arising out of delay or failure due to the hazards of drilling."
- Approximate Timelines & Equipment Detention (Section 8.2): Starting dates are approximate. Respondent is not liable for delays resulting from equipment detention or breakdown beyond contractor control.
- Force Majeure & Unavoidable Causes (Section 8.3): Respondent is relieved of performance obligations if work is delayed by labor conditions, unavoidable accidents, acts of God, or causes beyond reasonable control.
- Unstable Formations & Extra Charges (Section 4/8): Caving or unstable formations requiring the "drill and case" method increase drilling rates to hard rock pricing ($140/ft) plus per-foot charges for left-in-place conductor pipe.
- Duty to Provide Access (Section 7.2): Purchaser explicitly grants Respondent full right of access to perform work.
- Integration Clause (Section 8.11): The written contract constitutes the entire agreement between the parties, superseding all prior oral statements.
2.3 Operational Chronology: Equipment Setbacks, Subterranean Hazards, and Progression to 300 Feet
- Initial Startup Delay: Work startup was delayed because a prior project took longer than anticipated.
- Rig 1 Mobilization & Equipment Breakdown (March 2026): The first drill rig (Rig 1) arrived on site in March 2026 and drilled the initial 75 feet. Rig 1 then suffered a hydraulic pump breakdown requiring approximately $7,000 in repairs.
- Rig 2 Mobilization & Depth Progression (August 2026): A second drill rig (Rig 2) arrived on site in approximately August 2026 and drilled an additional 225 feet, bringing total borehole depth to 300 feet.
- Fuel Inflation: Operating the secondary rig involved higher fuel consumption amidst rising regional diesel prices from $4.50 to $8.00 per gallon.
- Early Breach by Complainant & Access Ban (November 2026): Drilling reached 300 feet before Complainant expressly stopped the work and barred site access, constituting an early breach of contract by Complainant.
2.4 License Status, Unreasonable Client Interference, Access Revocation, and Equipment Retention
Throughout the project, Respondent performed under difficult field conditions while attempting to maintain professional progress in the face of continuous, unreasonable client pressure, high-frequency communications, and hostility regarding completion dates outside contractual terms.
Respondent maintained active C-57 licensure (No. 1045746) during all physical drilling operations through October 31, 2026. Following October 31, 2026, a brief administrative expiration occurred due to renewal fee processing delays resulting from client non-payment on separate accounts.
On November 6, 2026, at 7:47 AM, Respondent texted Complainant: "I've made enough money to get it done so I'll b out thair soon," confirming administrative renewal funds were secured. Later that morning, Complainant texted: "Do not come out to our property to drill or do any further work."
By barring site access, Complainant reneged on the contract and unilaterally prevented Respondent from completing drilling down to 400 feet. Furthermore, Complainant has refused to allow Respondent to retrieve his drilling equipment from the property, creating substantial operational hardship for Respondent and delaying projects for other clients.
As of Wednesday, November 18, 2026, Respondent's C-57 License (No. 1045746) has been fully reinstated to active status by the CSLB.
III. POINT-BY-POINT RESPONSE TO ENUMERATED COMPLAINT ALLEGATIONS
Respondent provides the following specific legal and factual answers to the allegations in Part 4 of the Complaint:
Allegation 1: Alleged Abandonment / Failure to Complete (Bus. & Prof. Code § 7107)
Respondent's Answer: DENIED. Business and Professions Code § 7107 prohibits abandonment of a project "without legal excuse." Respondent never abandoned the project. Operational delays were legally excused under Section 8.1.3 (drilling hazards) and Section 8.3 (unavoidable equipment breakdowns and causes beyond control). Respondent paid $7,000 for hydraulic pump repairs, mobilized Rig 2, and drilled to 300 feet. On November 6, 2026, Respondent formally communicated readiness to return and finish the well. Prevention of performance by the owner constitutes a complete legal excuse under California law.
Allegation 2: Alleged Excess Down Payment (Bus. & Prof. Code § 7159)
Respondent's Answer: DENIED. The initial $4,000 received on October 28, 2025, represented reimbursement and prepayment for itemized pre-drilling costs: a $2,000 non-footage equipment move-on fee, $800+ in county permit fees and third-party permit representative handling charges, and specialized drill bits and mud-drilling equipment/supplies. The second payment ($16,000) was Milestone 2, contractually earned upon delivery of drilling machinery in March 2026. Respondent excavated 300 feet of borehole valued at $30,000, which exceeds total funds received ($21,030).
Allegation 3: Alleged Demand for Payment Beyond Contract (Bus. & Prof. Code § 7113)
Respondent's Answer: DENIED. Respondent did not demand improper payments outside the agreement. Section 4/8 of the contract explicitly provides that encountering unstable or caving ground invokes "drill and case" rates ($140/ft) and additional per-foot charges for left-in-place steel conductor pipe. Technical discussions regarding casing were essential recommendations to preserve the 300-foot open borehole against caving formations, fully authorized under Section 4/8.
Allegation 4: Alleged Departure from Permit and Plans (Bus. & Prof. Code §§ 7109, 7110)
Respondent's Answer: DENIED. The 120-foot figure on County Permit WP0040536 was a broad preliminary depth estimate submitted on the initial application by the third-party permit representative. In groundwater drilling, permit application depths reflect initial estimates, as exact subterranean water depths cannot be determined prior to drilling and drillers frequently must extend depth to strike viable water. The executed contract explicitly authorized drilling up to 400 feet ($100/ft). Hydrogeologically, 120 feet is insufficient to reach groundwater in this sub-basin. Under DWR protocols, final accurate depth and casing logs are recorded on DWR Form 188 upon completion of physical drilling. Because Complainant halted work, final filing was deferred.
Allegation 5: Alleged Failure to Provide Records
Respondent's Answer: DENIED. Under Section 5.6 of the contract and Water Code § 13751, the obligation to submit a final Water Well Drillers Report accrues within 30 days following project completion. Because operations were ongoing and halted by Complainant's access ban on November 6, 2026, the statutory filing deadline had not accrued. Respondent remains ready to supply all interim field depth logs up to 300 feet.
Allegation 6: Alleged Improper License Status (Bus. & Prof. Code § 7118 / § 7028)
Respondent's Answer: DENIED. Respondent maintained active C-57 licensure (No. 1045746) throughout all physical drilling activities from October 28, 2025, through October 31, 2026. Zero physical work occurred during the administrative expiration window following October 31, 2026. Following fee processing, CSLB officially reinstated License No. 1045746 to full active status as of Wednesday, November 18, 2026. Complainant suffered zero prejudice or harm.
Allegation 7: Alleged Financial Harm and Restitution Claim
Respondent's Answer: DENIED. Complainant claims restitution of $21,030 ($20,000 milestones + $1,030 fuel). However, Respondent deployed heavy rotary equipment, absorbed fuel costs, paid $7,000 for hydraulic pump repairs, and excavated 300 feet of borehole. At the contract drilling rate ($100/ft), the physical work delivered equals $30,000.00, which is $8,970.00 more than the $21,030.00 paid to date. Under the express terms of the drilling contract, Complainant is not entitled to any reimbursement or financial recovery.
IV. AFFIRMATIVE LEGAL DEFENSES
Respondent asserts the following affirmative legal defenses:
FIRST AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE: Prevention of Performance, Harassment, and Material Breach by Complainant (Civil Code § 1511)
Under California Civil Code § 1511(1), performance is legally excused when prevented or delayed by the act of the creditor. Section 7.2 of the contract required Complainant to grant Respondent full right of access. Complainant breached the agreement by subjecting Respondent to persistent harassment, demanding performance metrics outside contractual scope, and issuing an explicit text directive on November 6, 2026, barring Respondent from the property. By prohibiting access and withholding contractor equipment, Complainant committed a material breach and legally excused completion down to 400 feet.
SECOND AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE: Express Contractual Exculpation for Drilling Hazards & Force Majeure
Sections 8.1.3 and 8.3 explicitly relieve Respondent of liability for delay or failure caused by drilling hazards, equipment breakdowns, or causes beyond control. Setbacks resulting from the $7,000 Rig 1 hydraulic pump repair, fuel price inflation, and hard rock strata fall squarely within these protective provisions.
THIRD AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE: Unenforceability of July 18, 2026 Target Modification for Lack of Consideration
The July 18, 2026 handwritten target note (attached as an exhibit in Complainant's filing) lacked independent consideration under the established pre-existing duty rule of California contract law. Respondent executed this note solely as a good-faith attempt to appease Complainant during ongoing client pressure. Because Complainant provided no additional compensation, performance, or legal benefit in exchange, the handwritten note is legally unenforceable as a binding contract modification. Furthermore, the note did not alter or waive the express drilling hazard exculpations under Section 8.1.3 of the primary contract.
FOURTH AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE: Waiver of Completion Date by Course of Performance
Complainant implicitly waived strict adherence to the September 1 deadline by continuing coordination throughout September and October 2026, accepting depth progression updates to 300 feet, and purchasing $1,030 in operational fuel on October 17 and 24.
FIFTH AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE: Full Reinstatement of License
Because all physical labor occurred while actively licensed, and CSLB officially reinstated C-57 License No. 1045746 on November 18, 2026, no disciplinary violation under Business and Professions Code § 7118 or § 7028 exists.
V. UPDATED FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING AND QUANTUM MERUIT EVALUATION
Respondent provides the following transparent financial accounting of project receipts and delivered work value:
Summary of Funds Received and Work Rendered
| Payment Date | Description / Basis | Amount Received | Contractual / Operational Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10/28/2025 | Initial Allocation (Down Payment & Pass-Throughs) | $4,000.00 | Allocated to $2,000 Move-on Fee, $800+ Permit/Runner fees, and drill bits/mud supplies. |
| 03/18/2026 | Milestone 2: Delivery of drilling equipment | $16,000.00 | Contractually earned upon delivery of rotary rig to site. |
| 10/17/2026 & 10/24/2026 | Voluntary Diesel Fuel Support (SATA Food Mart) | $1,030.00 | Voluntarily provided by Complainant toward fuel costs. |
| N/A | Milestone 3: Bore hole completion | $0.00 | Unbilled; $10,000 milestone held until completion. |
| N/A | Milestone 4: Ready for pump installation | $0.00 | Unbilled; $10,000 milestone held until pump prep. |
| TOTAL RECEIVED | $21,030.00 | Substantive 300-ft borehole excavated. | |
Quantum Meruit Work Valuation
Under Section 2 of the contract, drilling is calculated at $100/ft:
Drilling Depth Completed (300 ft): 300 ft × $100/ft = $30,000.00
Total Value of Work Delivered: $30,000.00
Total Funds Received: $21,030.00
Net Value Delivered Beyond Payments Received: $8,970.00
The fair market value of the work delivered to Complainant ($30,000.00) exceeds all payments received ($21,030.00) by $8,970.00. Per the terms of the signed drilling contract, Complainant is not entitled to any reimbursement or financial recovery.
VI. PRAYER FOR RELIEF
WHEREFORE, Respondent Samuel Wayne Pettigrew, dba Pettigrew Well Drilling & Pump Repair, requests that the Contractors State License Board:
- DISMISS Complaint No. NA 2026008115 in its entirety with prejudice;
- FIND that project delays were out of Respondent's control and legally excused under Sections 8.1.3 and 8.3 of the contract;
- FIND that the initial $4,000 payment was properly allocated to equipment move-on fees ($2,000), county permit acquisition costs ($800+), and specialized drill bits/supplies, and that the permit depth entry of 120 ft was a preliminary estimate;
- FIND that Respondent did not abandon the project, but was prevented from completing drilling down to 400 feet by Complainant's access ban on November 6, 2026;
- FIND that Respondent's C-57 License No. 1045746 has been fully reinstated as of November 18, 2026, and all physical work was performed under active licensure;
- DENY Complainant's request for restitution, as Respondent rendered $30,000.00 in work value compared to $21,030.00 received;
- GRANT such further administrative relief as the Board deems just and proper.
Respectfully submitted,
Dated: November 18, 2026
_________________________________________
SAMUEL WAYNE PETTIGREW
In Propria Persona
dba Pettigrew Well Drilling & Pump Repair
10641 Allen Way, Lucerne Valley, CA 92356
VERIFICATION
I, Samuel Wayne Pettigrew, declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that I am the Respondent in the above-entitled administrative matter; that I have read the foregoing Revised Written Answer and Defense (Version 7) and know the contents thereof; and that the facts stated therein are true and correct of my own personal knowledge.
Executed on November 18, 2026, at Lucerne Valley, California.
_________________________________________
SAMUEL WAYNE PETTIGREW
10641 Allen Way, Lucerne Valley, CA 92356
Enclosures: (List any attached documents here)
CC: (List any copied parties here)
EXHIBIT INDEX
No exhibits were supplied with the source document. Reserved exhibit slots are provided below for insertion of supporting documentation.
EXHIBIT A — RESERVED FOR INSERTION
This section is reserved for the insertion of Exhibit A. Replace this placeholder with actual exhibit content when available.
EXHIBIT B — RESERVED FOR INSERTION
This section is reserved for the insertion of Exhibit B. Replace this placeholder with actual exhibit content when available.
EXHIBIT C — RESERVED FOR INSERTION
This section is reserved for the insertion of Exhibit C. Replace this placeholder with actual exhibit content when available.
APPENDIX: KEY LEGAL AND PROCEDURAL REFERENCES
- California Business and Professions Code § 7107 — Abandonment of a project without legal excuse
- California Business and Professions Code § 7113 — Demand for payment beyond contract terms
- California Business and Professions Code § 7118 — License requirements and violations
- California Business and Professions Code § 7159 — Excess down payment limitations
- California Business and Professions Code § 7028 — License status and disciplinary provisions
- California Business and Professions Code § 7109, § 7110 — Departure from permit and plans
- California Civil Code § 1511 — Prevention of performance excuse
- California Water Code § 13751 — Water Well Drillers Report filing requirements
- Ground Water Institute of California (GWIC) Standard Form Drilling Contract
- San Bernardino County Permit WP0040536
- DWR Form 188 — Final Depth and Casing Log